Loading preview...

Features

  • A poster of six discussion norms, each with a tip
  • Eight role cards: Leader, Questioner, Connector, Summarizer, Evidence Finder, Word Watcher, Recorder and Timekeeper
  • 8 talk cards with starters for evidence, linking ideas and respectful disagreement
  • A discussion prep sheet with room for evidence and a question
  • Discussion notes: key ideas, who said them and the group's conclusion
  • A self-check for me and my group, before, during and after
  • Every page in color and in black and white

Skills Covered

  • Come to discussions prepared
  • Follow discussion rules and roles
  • Back up ideas with evidence
  • Ask and answer specific questions
  • Build on others' remarks
  • Sum up key ideas and draw conclusions

How to Use This Pack

Seven pages for small-group discussion of a text. Page 1 is a poster of six norms. Pages 2 and 3 are eight role cards, four for a group and four more to add or trade. Page 4 is eight talk cards. Page 5 is the prep sheet students fill in before the talk, page 6 the notes and conclusion they write during and after it, and page 7 a self-check for each student and the group.

In the Classroom

Agree on the norms and post them. Start with the first four roles, model each one in a fishbowl, then add Evidence Finder, Word Watcher, Recorder and Timekeeper as groups grow. Assign the prep sheet as homework the night before a book talk, and have the Summarizer share each group's conclusion with the class.

At Home

Read the same article or chapter as your child, then talk about it. Ask: where in the text did you see that? and try a card like What I hear you saying is...

Tips for Success

  • Prepare with evidence and a question
  • Point to the text to back up an idea
  • Connect what you say to what was said
  • Challenge the idea, never the person
  • Sum up what the group decided

Discussion Roles and Talk Cards for 4th–5th Grade

4th – 5th Grade

Discussion norms, role cards and talk cards for small-group discussions about a text. Students prepare with evidence, take on a role, use starters to build on ideas and disagree respectfully, record key ideas and sum up what the group decided.

Download PDF
Pin

Also for other grades

What’s Included

  • 1 discussion norms poster
  • 8 role cards on 2 pages
  • 8 talk cards
  • 1 discussion prep sheet
  • 1 discussion notes page
  • 1 self-check
Can’t find what you need?

Tell us what to make next, or build your own with a worksheet maker.

Suggest a worksheet

Free to print and share

This worksheet is free to download, print, copy, and hand out in your classroom or at home. You do not need to create an account, and there are no watermarks on the PDF.